
|
 |
Paint, Stain, Varnish, or Preservative?
Life span of different kinds of finishes
Water repellents 6–12 months Clear water-repellent preservatives 1–2
years Pigmented water-repellent preservatives 2–3 years Varnish 2–3
years Solid-color stains 3–7 years
Semitransparent stains 3–8 years Paints 7–10 years Note: The life span
of water repellents, water-repellent preservatives (clear or
pigmented), and semitransparent stains can be extended by refinishing
if discoloration caused by mildew or other factors is a problem. If
you’ve ever admired an old, unpainted barn that has survived 100 years
or more of weather, it’s easy to wonder why you should use a finish on
your home. However, the cracks, fissures, and air spaces that give
weathered barn siding its character wouldn’t be acceptable on most
houses. While you can’t completely arrest or reverse the weathering of
exterior wood, you can slow the process dramatically by using the right
type of finish. Appearance, durability, cost, ease of application, and
maintenance should all be considered when selecting an exterior finish.
Two basic types of finishes or treatments are used to protect wood
surfaces from weathering: those that form a film or coating on the wood
(film-forming finishes) and those that penetrate the wood surface.
Film-forming materials include paints, solid-color stains, and
varnishes. Penetrating finishes include preservatives, water
repellents, and pigmented semitransparent stains. What you choose to
protect and enhance the beauty of wood always involves trade-offs. You
should select the finish that best suits the application.
Film-Forming Finishes
Paints
Latex is best
Paints form a thin layer over the surface to which they’re applied. The
pigments in the paint protect the surface completely from the damaging
ultraviolet (UV) rays of the sun and erosion. The finish retards the
movement of moisture into and out of the wood and seals in the natural
resins. However, paint won’t prevent decay if conditions are favorable
for fungal growth. Oil-base or alkyd paints are essentially suspensions
of inorganic pigments in an oil or modified oil vehicle that binds the
pigment particles to the wood surface. Latex paints are suspensions of
inorganic pigments and various latex resins in water.
Acrylic latex resins
They are
flexible and very durable. A good acrylic latex outdoor house paint
will generally outlast a good oil-base house paint. Latex paints are
also more porous than oil-base paints; they can “breathe” while they
shed water. This characteristic may contribute to their longevity. If
water enters the wall from an interior source, it’s more likely to get
trapped in the wood beneath an oil-base finish, and it can cause the
paint to blister. Moreover, oil base paints tend to become brittle.
Acrylic polymers
They are more
resistant to sunlight than oil-base paints and therefore do not weather
as quickly. However, woods like redwood and cedar have water-soluble
extractives that can bleed through latex paints. The best way to
prevent this is to seal the wood with an oil-base or stain blocking
latex primer paint, thentopcoat with acrylic latex paint. Wood is
easier to repaint before the first coat fails. Paints weather away;
self-cleaning paints weather at a faster rate than other paints.
Ideally, wood should be repainted when the topcoats have weathered to
the point that the primer is just starting to show. Painting too often
can build up too many layers of paint.
The north side of a building does not need to be repainted as often as
other sides because it is exposed to less direct sunlight. Apply one
topcoat to this side instead of two, or paint this side less often. The
optimum thickness for a primer and two topcoats is 4 to 5 mils (1 mil =
1/1000 of an inch), about the thickness of a sheet of newspaper.
If the paint has peeled, the easiest way to prepare the wood for
repainting is by power washing. Power washing or sanding (with 50–80
grit sandpaper) also
Varnishes
Varnish is another
film-formingfinish. However, because varnishes= are clear, they require
frequentmaintenance to be attractive.Sunlight degrades both the
varnishand the wood fibers directlybeneath it. Some varnishes
havechemicals that partially block UVradiation, but varnishes all
soonbegin to crack, peel, and flake,taking along the fibers of photochemicallydegraded wood. Thewood needs to be cleaned
andrevarnished as soon as thisbreakdown occurs. Varnish lastsonly 1 to
2 years on wood exposedto full sun, but longer on shadedwood. The life
span of varnish canbe extended by first staining thewood and then
applying many coats of varnish.
Penetrating Finishes:
Penetrating
finishes absorb intothe wood, saturating the surfacefibers and
partially or completelyfilling the surface pores. Manypenetrating
finishes contain waterrepellents, usually in the form ofparaffin wax
dissolved in mineralspirits.
Water repellents are usually clear. They can be used alone as a natural
penetrating finish or as a treatment prior to painting. Check the label
of the finish to make sure that it is paintable. Many clear penetrating
finishes contain wood preservatives in addition to water repellents;
these penetrating finishes are much better for outdoor use. The
preservatives control the growth of mildew and other fungi. Some
preservatives also discourage insect infestation. This is especially
important in moist, shady locations. Water-repellent emulsions have
been developed for waterborne formulations, but these may not penetrate
as well as the formulations made with mineral spirits.
Semitransparent Stains
Oil:
It is Best Semitransparent
stains are penetrating finishes with inorganic pigments. High quality
stains contain wood preservatives and water repellents. Semitransparent
stains penetrate the wood without forming a film, allowing much of the
wood grain to show through the finish. Latex-base semitransparent
stains are film-forming finishes and will not perform like true
penetrating stains. Oil-base semitransparent stains allow the wood to
“breathe,” so the finish doesn’t blister or peel even if the moisture
content of the wood is high. The pigment in a semitransparent
penetrating stain greatly increases the durability of the finish by
absorbing much of the UV radiation that would otherwise degrade the
wood. The properties of the pigment, resin, preservative, and water
repellent determine the durability of exterior stains. Penetrating
stains perform best on rough-sawn, weathered, or coarse-textured wood.
If you are finishing smooth wood, power wash, sand, or wet the surface
to relieve stresses and open the surface pores. Unlike paints, stains
can be applied to weathered surfaces without preparing the surface. If
the surface is dirty or has mildew, clean it with bleach and detergent
before applying the finish. Penetrating stains are suitable for siding,
trim, exposed decking, fences, and roof shingles. Stains may be applied
by brush, spray, or roller. To prevent lap marks, finish the board or
panel in one working session.
Working in the shade will give the best results because longer drying
time means greater penetration of the stain. For best results,
rough-sawn or weathered lumber should be treated with two coats of
penetrating stain; the second coat should be applied before the first
is dry. If the first coat has completely dried, it may seal the wood
surface so that the second coat scarcely penetrates. To prevent
formation of a film, an hour after applying the second coat, use a
cloth, sponge, or dry brush lightly wetted with stain to wipe off any
excess stain improves the ability of new smooth siding to hold paint
and removes weathered fibers of unfinished wood that have been exposed
to sunlight for more than a few weeks. Before applying paint, treat
wood siding and trim with a paintable water-repellent preservative.
This can be done by brush after the siding or trim is in place, or by
dipping the wood before installation. All lap and butt joints of solid
wood and all panel edges should be especially well-saturated. Allow the
treatment to dry for at least 2 warm, sunny days before applying the
primer. If the wood has been dip treated, let it dry for about a week.
Two coats of a good quality acrylic latex house paint should be applied
over the primer. In general, quality is directly related to price.
Brush application is always superior to roller or spray application,
especially with the first coat. The job can be done faster if one
person sprays the paint and another uses a brush to work the paint into
the wood and even it out. Each coat should be applied within 2 weeks of
the previous one, to avoid formation of a slick soaplike or chalky
substance on the surface. If more than 2 weeks have elapsed, scrub the
paint with water and a stiff-bristled brush before applying the next
coat. Temperature is important. Don’t paint on a cool surface that will
be heated by the sun within a few hours or at the end of a cool day
when heavy dew will form at night. The temperature must stay above 40° for 24 hours for oil paints and above 50° for latex.
Solid-Color Stains Solid-color
stains also form a film. They look and act like thin paints. Use a
primer and two coats of stain. Refinishing may require only one coat.
Like paints, latex solid color stains are usually more durable than
oil-base stains. Solid color stains are preferable to paints when the
wood is refinished frequently that did not penetrate the wood. Remember
that sponges or cloths soaked with oil-base or alkyd-base stains are
particularly susceptible to spontaneous combustion; they should be
buried, immersed in water, or sealed in an airtight metal container.
Natural Finishes
A natural finish means different things to different people. To some, a
natural look means rough, gray, and weathered (nature’s “natural
finish”). To others, a successful natural exterior wood finish is one
that retains the original, attractive appearance of the wood with the
least change in color and the least masking of the grain and surface
texture. In this case, the finish should inhibit the growth of mildew
micro organisms, protect against moisture and sunlight, and not change
the surface appearance or color of the wood.
The “weathered look” can be obtained in several ways. Do nothing until
the wood turns gray, then treat the wood regularly with a
water-repellent preservative or a gray semitransparent stain. This will
extend the life of the wood. If you want to obtain a weathered look
quickly, apply a gray stain; as the stain weathers, the wood will turn
gray naturally. Maintain the finish with a stain or water repellent
preservative. You can preserve the original color of the wood in
several ways. From the start, treat the wood with a water-repellent
preservative at least once a year, or apply a semitransparent oil-base
stain (containing a water repellent and preservative) of the same color
as the wood. The pigment in the stain protects the wood and extends the
life of the preservative. If the wood turns gray, the preservative has
failed. Most gray discoloration is caused by mildew. Power washing,
bleach, and some commercial cleaners remove gray discoloration. In
general, it is best to paint over a fairly smooth and stable surface.
Flat-sawn and dense woods can be stabilized with a resin-treated paper
overlay. This type of lamination is most frequently applied over
exterior plywood or stabilized fiberboard, and it makes an excellent
surface for painting. Rough-sawn exterior plywood siding is best
finished with a semitransparent penetrating stain or solid-color latex
stain.
Preservatives
Preservative-treated wood such as wood pressure-treated with chromated
copper arsenate (CCA) is frequently used for outdoor porches and decks.
After a few years, some boards may check or crack as part of the
natural weathering process. Weathering can be reduced by using a
penetrating finish that contains a water repellent early in the
finishing process. Allowing a deck to weather for a year opens the
surface pores and permits the wood to accept more finish, but this
weathering damages the wood. Research indicates that it is better to
finish a deck as soon as it is dry (a few weeks after construction) and
to refinish it in 2 years. To paint treated wood, make sure the wood is
clean and dry. Porches and decks can be painted, but be prepared for
problems like decay, a slippery surface, cracking, checking, and
flaking. Use a very good porch and deck enamel for the two topcoats.
Water-repellent preservatives and semitransparent penetrating stains
must be reapplied more frequently than paint, but reapplication is
easy. Simply brush a generous amount of finish onto the wood; after 20
to 40 min, wipe off any excess finish that remains on the surface.
Wood Properties
Since wood properties vary, the type of wood is an important
consideration in choosing a finish. Wood that has minimum tendency to
shrink and swell is the best for painting because there’s less chance
that the paint will crack as the wood shrinks and swells.
Vertical-grained (edge-grained) wood is subject to about half the
shrinking and swelling of flat-grained lumber. Wood density also
affects swelling. Low-density woods are better for painting than denser
species. Low density softwoods like western
Red Cedar and redwood have excellent properties for finishing; pine and
fir also retain paint well, particularly if the wood is free of knots.
As more wood is being cut from younger trees, more boards are
containing juvenile wood— wood formed during the first few years of
growth. Juvenile wood shrinks and swells at a very high rate and
requires a penetrating finish. Like wood with knots, juvenile wood
easily releases extractives, which bleed through paint.
Mark Knaebe is a chemist in Wood Finishing Research at the USDA Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory
|
|
|
 |
|